New York City

Change Location

Zagat Rated

American Hotel, The

The American Hotel|49 Main St. (bet. Bay & Washington Sts.) Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Phone:
631-725-3535
Website:
www.theamericanhotel.com
Type:
Bar
Neighborhood:
Sag Harbor

Top Listed

American Hotel, The is featured in these top lists:

American Hotel, The Stats

Payment:

  • Accepts Major Credit Cards

Dress Code:

  • Upscale Casual

Date Opened:

  • Jan. 1846

Good For:

  • Celebrity Sightings
  • Expense Accounters
  • Mature Crowds
  • Quiet Conversation

Vibe / Atmosphere:

  • Swanky

Special Features:

  • Food Menu Available
  • Outdoor Seating:
    • Patio
  • Valet Parking

Hours:

  • Mon: 12:00PM - 12:00AM
  • Tues: 12:00PM - 12:00AM
  • Wed: 12:00PM - 12:00AM
  • Thur: 12:00PM - 12:00AM
  • Fri: 12:00PM - 2:00AM
  • Sat: 12:00PM - 2:00AM
  • Sun: 12:00PM - 12:00AM
Send us a Correction

ZAGAT Ratings & Review

Food Decor Service Cost
? ? ? ?
Become a Premium Member Today

19 Member Reviews for:
American Hotel, The

  • 1-5 of 19

Reviewed by Jeffrey W. on 07/23/2008.
Member since May 2002, Total Reviews: 81 (Sarasota, FL)

Subdued attitude; guardedly friendly and a great bar.

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review
Register for FREE to add your review

Reviewed by JeffreyA237225 on 07/09/2008.
Member since March 2001, Total Reviews: 51 (Male, 50s, Bronx, NY)

Tom has complete control of the dinning room. The food is out of this world great and is the closest thing to a gourmet restaurant you will find in the Hampton's Lamb chops and shrimp cocktail a must.

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review

Reviewed by Bridge on 05/27/2008.
Member since January 2003, Total Reviews: 6 (Bronx, NY)

A delightful classic!

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review

Reviewed by JonG1369 on 05/27/2008.
Member since February 2007, Total Reviews: 2 (Male, 40s, Shaker Hts, OH)

A friend of mine recently disclosed that he passed on an opportunity to purchase the Ameircan Hotel in the 70's and has since rued the day he did so! A Fantastic spot with excellent fare, service and decor. A pleathora of people watching opportunities as the "it" spot when looking for a special evening and great meal in Sag Harbor.

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review
Register for FREE to add your review

Reviewed by chiefstar on 05/27/2008.
Member since November 2002, Total Reviews: 40 (New Hyde Park, NY)

Bring your date for a romantic adventure and sip fine wine from their extensive list.

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review
  • 1-5 of 19
You can now add member reviews on your phone at ZAGAT.mobi. Learn More

For Business Owners

Find Places Near American Hotel, The

2010 New York City Restaurants

2010 New York City Restaurants

This new guide is packed with over 2,000 ratings of the best restaurants in New York City.

Shop Now