Your location: New York City

Zagat Rated

Brother Jimmy's BBQ

428 Amsterdam Ave. (bet. 80th & 81st Sts.) Manhattan, NY 10024
Phone:
212-501-7515
Type:
Restaurant, Sports Bar
Neighborhood:
West 80s

Top Listed

Brother Jimmy's BBQ is featured in these top lists:

Brother Jimmy's BBQ Stats

Reservations:

  • Not Taken

Payment:

  • Accepts Major Credit Cards

Dress Code:

  • Casual

Date Opened:

  • Mar. 1998

Vibe / Atmosphere:

  • Frat House
  • Meat Market

Special Features:

  • Food Menu Available
  • Games
  • Happy Hour
  • Karaoke Nights
  • Live Entertainment (other than music)
  • Music
  • Outdoor Seating:
    • Sidewalk

Hours:

  • Mon: 4:00PM - 2:00AM
  • Tues: 4:00PM - 2:00AM
  • Wed: 4:00PM - 2:00AM
  • Thur: 12:00PM - 2:00AM
  • Fri: 12:00PM - 4:00AM
  • Sat: 12:00PM - 4:00AM
  • Sun: 12:00PM - 2:00AM

ZAGAT Ratings & Review

Food Decor Service Cost
? ? ? ?

255 Member Reviews for:
Brother Jimmy's BBQ

  • 1-5 of 255

Reviewed by JohnM2711 on 01/25/2010.
Member since January 2010, Total Reviews: 14 (New York, NY)

nicer than other options in Murray Hill

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review

Reviewed by AshleyM2683 on 01/24/2010.
Member since January 2010, Total Reviews: 7 (New York, NY)

Good place for happy hour, especially when the other places are packed. Catfish po'boy is amazing

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review

Reviewed by TanaR2753 on 01/24/2010.
Member since September 2009, Total Reviews: 32 (New York, NY)

This bar is more of a meat market than the other Brother Jimmy's locations I've been to. It's located along a strip of popular bars on Amsterdam, which makes it pretty much part of the inevitable Friday and Saturday bar crawling. For this reason, it's always loud and packed. However, it's definitely a pick-up spot.

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review

Reviewed by ZoeF2570 on 01/24/2010.
Member since January 2010, Total Reviews: 12 (Brooklyn, NY)

skip this vomit-smelling location for any of it's others for the best bbq in NY and NC.

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review

Reviewed by Hutner5000 on 01/24/2010.
Member since April 2007, Total Reviews: 7 (Hoboken, NJ)

I'm just bitter that it opened right after i moved out of the neighborhood. Always nice to have a good bbq joint around the corner with lotsa tvs for sporting events. Half my workmates enjoy living at this place.

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review
  • 1-5 of 255
You can now add member reviews on your phone at ZAGAT.mobi. Learn More

For Business Owners

Find Places Near Brother Jimmy's BBQ

2010 New York City Restaurants

2010 New York City Restaurants

This new guide is packed with over 2,000 ratings of the best restaurants in New York City.