42

Reviewed by PhilT1107648 on 06/29/2009.
Member since October 2002, Total Reviews: 28 (Yonkers, NY)

i can understand the negative reviews when service was weak and prices, whcih have copme down) were sky high. the views are DEFINITELY worth a premium. we had 4 courses, plus amuse bouche and petit fours, sparkling wine with first 2 then wine by the glass for second 2. everyjhting we ate was top notch and generously portioned. the service was impeccable and the place was JAMMED. Anthony is a master and i cannot wait to return.

Reviewed by Salokina71507 on 06/08/2009.
Member since October 2003, Total Reviews: 17 (Female, 30s, Bronx, NY)

Anthony Gonclaves was in trotters restaurant incredible. 42 is not good. The food was poor. The fish was horrible must have been a bad dish but my wife complained that it was not good too. The dessert were nice but whatever. I will never go back again!

1 out of 1 people found the following review helpful:

Reviewed by KrisM558935 on 05/26/2009.
Member since February 2005, Total Reviews: 27 (30s, Union City, NJ)

Sorely disappointed with Anthony Goncalves' new attempt at "high" society and over-rated for the hype its created in White Plains. The slow bar service began a rough evening with seating well after our reservation time. Then having no options for vegetarians except to add more spinach to an already small portion. Bread sticks and dessert show the culinary creativity that the rest of the meal lacked.

2 out of 2 people found the following review helpful:

Reviewed by RoseP0309 on 05/18/2009.
Member since January 2008, Total Reviews: 27 (Female, 50s, Mahopac, NY)

I've never been treated with such disrespect. I asked for a table near the window on a tuesday night, when the entire dining room was empty, and i was told they were all reserved. After our appetizer course, at around 8:00, the tables were not filled, i paid my check and walked out.

Reviewed by ClaudineG149118 on 05/05/2009.
Member since November 1999, Total Reviews: 8 (Female, 30s, Hartsdale, NY)

Absolutely beautiful restaurant on the top of the Renaissance in White Plains. Views of Manhattan as you dine on the 42nd floor. Chef came out to talk to guests at the end of the night. Hors d'ouevres were complimentary and so was the "flight" of mini desserts. Very well done. Delicious food. Can't wait to return.