New York City

Zagat Rated

American Hotel, The

The American Hotel|49 Main St. (bet. Bay Ave. & Washington Sts.) Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Phone:
631-725-3535
Fax:
725-3573
Website:
www.theamericanhotel.com
Cuisine:
American (Traditional), French
Neighborhood:
Sag Harbor

Top Listed

American Hotel, The is featured in these top lists:

American Hotel, The Stats

Meals Served:

  • Dinner
  • Lunch

Reservations:

  • Suggested (Highly)

Payment:

  • Accepts Major Credit Cards

Dress Code:

  • Upscale Casual

Date Opened:

  • Nov. 1946

Good For:

  • Expense Accounters
  • People Watching
  • Romance

Special Features:

  • Dramatic Interiors
  • Fireplace
  • Game Served
  • Live Entertainment
  • Private Room Available
  • Winning Wine List

Vibe / Atmosphere:

  • Power Scene

Special Meals & Menus:

  • Children's Menu

Hours:

  • Mon: 12:00PM - 10:00PM
  • Tues: 12:00PM - 10:00PM
  • Wed: 12:00PM - 10:00PM
  • Thurs: 12:00PM - 10:00PM
  • Fri: 12:00PM - 11:00PM
  • Sat: 12:00PM - 11:00PM
  • Sun: 12:00PM - 10:00PM

ZAGAT Ratings & Review

Food Decor Service Cost
? ? ? ?

169 Member Reviews for:
American Hotel, The

  • 1-5 of 169

Reviewed by CM47681 on 05/05/2009.
Member since April 2000, Total Reviews: 96 (Levittown, NY)

This is a great place as a destination for a pleasant lunch or dinner. The food is great as well as the service. It has a good bar and nice atmosphere. The wine list is extensive no matter what country you prefer. Seating is comfortable, converstation friendly.

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review

Reviewed by MrSpock on 03/22/2009.
Member since October 2002, Total Reviews: 41 (Male, 60 and above, New Suffolk, NY)

Very good, classic food (no new or unusual preparations). Good, sometimes excellent service but some tendency to be slow, and occasionally too much attitude. Attractive if a bit overstuffed decor.

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review

Reviewed by scottv682669 on 11/22/2008.
Member since June 1999, Total Reviews: 53 (Rivervale, NJ)

A little staid, stuffy and overpriced, however the food is always good, decor is nice

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review

Reviewed by barbarar205577 on 11/22/2008.
Member since May 2002, Total Reviews: 51 (Sag Harbor, NY)

Hit or miss.

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review

Reviewed by jamesr4905 on 11/22/2008.
Member since November 2008, Total Reviews: 1 (Stony Brook, NY)

great time

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review
  • 1-5 of 169
You can now add member reviews on your phone at ZAGAT.mobi. Learn More

Find Places Near American Hotel, The

2010 New York City Restaurants

2010 New York City Restaurants

This new guide is packed with over 2,000 ratings of the best restaurants in New York City.