New York City

Change Location

Zagat Rated

Peter's Italian Restaurant

This property is closed .
132 W. Main St. (Carll Ave.) Babylon, NY 11702
Phone:
631-422-9233
Fax:
631-422-9234
Cuisine:
Italian
Neighborhood:
Babylon

Peter's Italian Restaurant Stats

Meals Served:

  • Dinner
  • Lunch

Payment:

  • Accepts Major Credit Cards

Dress Code:

  • Casual

Date Opened:

  • Jan. 1990

Special Features:

  • Live Entertainment
  • Outdoor Seating:
    • Patio
  • Private Room Available
  • Takeout Available

Special Meals & Menus:

  • All Day Dining

Hours:

  • Mon: 12:00PM - 10:30PM
  • Tues: 12:00PM - 10:30PM
  • Wed: 12:00PM - 10:30PM
  • Thurs: 12:00PM - 10:30PM
  • Fri: 12:00PM - 11:00PM
  • Sat: 12:00PM - 11:00PM
  • Sun: 12:00PM - 9:00PM
Update or Add to this Information

ZAGAT Ratings & Review

Food Decor Service Cost
? ? ? ?
Become a Premium Member Today

24 Member Reviews for:
Peter's Italian Restaurant

  • 1-5 of 24

Reviewed by GraceannM3240 on 11/01/2008.
Member since November 2008, Total Reviews: 12 (West Islip, NY)

food was good, owner is very much like he was depicted on TV.

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review
Register for FREE to add your review
0 out of 1 people found the following review helpful:

Reviewed by jsloss28 on 10/29/2008.
Member since February 2007, Total Reviews: 3 (Male, 30s, Babylon, NY)

Reliable food. Great little garden in back.

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review
1 out of 1 people found the following review helpful:

Reviewed by richmonte71 on 10/29/2008.
Member since September 2008, Total Reviews: 6 (Male, 30s, Bellport, NY)

They ran out of cranberry juice for my drink, so they brought it to me with some other red juice and tried to pass it off as a vodka cran. Has empty glasses 2 x. They werent even busy. I wont be back

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review
1 out of 1 people found the following review helpful:

Reviewed by DebbyL7922 on 10/27/2008.
Member since October 2008, Total Reviews: 14 (Babylon, NY)

OK, I couldn't get my fork out of my meatball it was so hard. Thsi place was wonderful about 10 years ago. Now, we do a drive right by this place.

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review
Register for FREE to add your review
1 out of 1 people found the following review helpful:

Reviewed by JenniferC7204 on 10/23/2008.
Member since September 2008, Total Reviews: 27 (Oak Beach, NY)

SOLD! Are we suprised?

Was this review helpful to you? Add Your ReviewReport This Review
  • 1-5 of 24
You can now add member reviews on your phone at ZAGAT.mobi. Learn More

Find Places Near Peter's Italian Restaurant

2010 New York City Restaurants

2010 New York City Restaurants

This new guide is packed with over 2,000 ratings of the best restaurants in New York City.

Shop Now