My long-time favorite is Fino, in the Andrews Hotel on Post St at Taylor, about 2 blocks from the theater. There is a valet parking lot in Cosmo Place, enter from Taylor Street, and an entrance to the restaurant from Cosmo. Extensive Italian menu, lots of vegetarian choices, lovely two-part dining room with fireplace, small but not too cramped, full bar. Reasonably priced, especially for the area, interesting wines, many Italian.