P.J. Carney’s

Irish Pub | West 50s

Atmo.20 Decor16 Service22 CostI

Ratings are out of 30. Key to ratings Question

Zagat ratings

Zagat calculates ratings on a 30-point scale based on periodic consumer surveys

26 - 30
Extraordinary to Perfection
21 - 25
Very Good to Excellent
16 - 20
Good to Very Good
11 - 15
Fair to Good
0 - 10
Poor to Fair

A “pub right out of the old world”, this circa-1927 Irish joint hard by Carnegie Hall is an “easygoing” pit stop for chatting with “friendly bartenders” who keep the suds “continuously flowing”; “convenient” enough to attract “tourists and locals” alike, it’s typically “busy.”

Learn how Zagat writes reviews »