American Hotel Restaurant
- American (Traditional), French
- Sag Harbor
The American Hotel49 Main St. (bet. Bay & Washington Sts.)Long Island, NY 11963www.theamericanhotel.com
- 631-725-3535
Make a Reservation
Stats
- # of Reviews:
- 664
- American (Traditional) Rank:
- 6 of 109
- Sag Harbor Rank:
- 1 of 22
- Members Been Here:
- 12
- Member Favorites:
- 4
Member Reviews
Most Recent Reviews
-
a little pricey but not for the area, food is good and the seriv ce is even better....
Published February 10, 2012 -
- Premium Member
The "Hotel" has wonderful old world charm, with impeccable food and service. The bar is the perfect meeting place for pre or post dinner drinks with friends.The best that historic Sag Harbor has to offer, as well as the other surrounding towns in the Hamptons
Published January 17, 2012 -
The chicken breast was the size of a pigeon , tasted as good and was massively overpriced for what it was.The service was pretentious and really bad.nothing nice to say for my last visit.
Published July 11, 2011 -
We have avoided this place for a while because from the outside it looks very stuffy but we were wrong. The decor is a old school American and service is impeccable. I had the long island duck that was by far the best I have had in the Hamptons and my fiancé had the rack of lamb which was done to perfection. The wine BOOK will please any wine connoisseur and the desert will satisfy any sweet tooth. We left full and happy and I must admit we are picky eaters!
Published June 1, 2011 -
fantastic food, the most amazing creme brulee' ever!
Published November 20, 2010
Good to Know
- Atmosphere
- Power Scene
- Features
- Dramatic Interiors
Fireplace
Game Served
Private Room Available
Winning Wine List
- Meals
- Lunch Served
Dinner Served
- Signature Dishes
- Filet Mignon Of Angus Maitre D'hotel
Porterhouse Fiorentina
Connect With American Hotel Restaurant
Nov. 2006