Bay Burger

Hamburgers
Sag Harbor

1742 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Tpke. (Carroll St.)Long Island, NY 11963www.bayburger.com

631-899-3915

Zagat Ratings & Review

Unlock these scores for the real story.

Food	Decor	Service	Cost

Trusted Zagat Ratings and Reviews help take the guesswork out of finding the perfect restaurant.

Stats

# of Reviews:: 103
Hamburgers Rank:: 3 of 31
Sag Harbor Rank:: 8 of 22
Members Been Here:: 1
Member Favorites:: 0

Add to Lists

Added! Go to List »

Member Reviews

See Reviews From Other Publications

Most Recent Reviews

Carl A

2 Reviews

Member since:
Jul. 2011
Burgers always made to order perfectly, great family-friendly atmosphere, best comfort food in the Hamptons.

Published July 3, 2011
Was this review helpful?
Yes No
- Report This
Sheila S

1 Reviews

Winthrop

Member since:
Nov. 2008
Bay Burger is possibly the best burger place I have ever been to - bar none. They bake their rolls fresh every day and grind their hamburger as well. Any other burger I have ever had pales in comparison to the fresh flavor, incredible quality and totally delicious burgers at Bay Burger. They are the Tiffany's of burgers and Bay Burger is the jewel in the crown of Long Island. Sheila

Published November 18, 2010
Was this review helpful?
Yes No
- Report This
todd b

58 Reviews

New York

Member since:
Jan. 2005
Foodie
THE BEST LUNCH IN SAG HARBOR!!

Published November 8, 2010
Was this review helpful?
Yes No
- Report This
Matt M

13 Reviews

Wainscott

Member since:
Nov. 2010
Small Portions but food is good!

Published November 8, 2010
Was this review helpful?
Yes No
- Report This
laura e

7 Reviews

Bellerose

Member since:
Oct. 2010
I can't see why this burger place is even on the list!

Published October 31, 2010
Was this review helpful?
Yes No
- Report This

See all 55 reviews »

See More Photos »

Good to Know

Features: Patio
Private Room Available
Takeout Available

Meals: Lunch Served
Dinner Served

Signature Dishes: Burgers On Freshly Baked Buns
Hot Dogs; Grilled Cheese