Fatty's Cafe

  • American (Traditional), Eclectic / Int'l
  • Astoria
25-01 Ditmars Blvd. (Crescent St.)New York City, NY 11105
  • 718-267-7071

Zagat Ratings & Review

Unlock these scores for the real story.

Food Decor Service Cost

Trusted Zagat Ratings and Reviews help take the guesswork out of finding the perfect restaurant.

Stats

87%
Liked it
# of Reviews:
118
American (Traditional) Rank:
21 of 203
Astoria Rank:
34 of 99
Members Been Here:
3
Member Favorites:
3

BRUNCH

Specials
Includes choice of Mimosa, Bloody Mary or Limeade Price: $9.00
Two Egg Hook Up Any style served with home fries and choice of bacon, ham, sausage, or black beans
Eggless Sunnyside Up Provolone sandwiched between two polenta corn cakes served with mesclun salad and choice of bacon, ham, sausage or black beans
Big Fat Pancake Omelette Two pancakes stuffed with raspberries, strawberries, blueberries and bananas served with maple syrup
La Pistola Two fried eggs on a bed of rice and beans, served with tortillas
Cuban Sandi Half of cubano, served with mesclun salad
Make Your Own Omelette Two eggs stuffed with choice of four: Onion, mushroom, green pepper, red pepper, spinach, scallion, served with home fries and choice of bacon, ham, sausage or black bean
The Fatty Sweet sausage patty, egg, choice of cheese, swiss, cheddar, provolone or monterray; on an English muffin served with mesclun salad
Ensalada Especial Fatty's special salad with your choice of one: Chicken, steak, shrimp, Portobello, or avocado
Sides
Tostones or maduros  $2.50
Mister Fantasy  $5.00
French Fries  $2.50
Bacon, Ham, Sausage or Black Beans  $2.50
Rice & Beans  $2.50
Extras
Egg Whites  $1.00
Choice of Cheese  $1.00
Toast, English Muffin, Tortillas  $1.50

DINNER

Goodies
Fatty's Grilled Cheese of the Day Market Price 
Empanadas (two per order) beef or cheese $5.00
Grilled Shrimp (five per order) with choice of dipping sauce *
  • *marinara, garlic aioli, or lime aioli 
 $8.00
House Chili Seasoned ground beef with vegetables and black beans topped with cheddar, raw onion and sour cream, served with tortilla chips $8.00
Hummus & Pita Served with cucumber and tomato $6.00
Yucca Rellena Pureed yucca rolled over a medley of seafood then breaded and deep fried to a crispy finish, served with wasabi sauce $8.00
Mexican Seafood Cocktai Scallops and shrimp in tomato broth seasoned with herbs and mixed with diced avocado $8.00
Salads
Price: $6.00
Pick One: Romaine, Mesclun, Iceberg, or Baby Spinach
Choose up to four: Tomato, red onions, green peppers, red peppers, carrots, mushrooms, sprouts, beets, olives, granny smith apples, cucumbers, almonds or sesame seeds
Dressings: Carrot-Tahini, Citrus-Garlic Vinaigrette, Trinagre, Fatty's House Dressing
Add some extras: 
  • Cheddar, feta, bleu, or mozzarella $1.00
  • Chicken $4.00
  • steak $4.00
  • shrimp $5.00
  • avocado $2.00
  • Portobello $2.00
  • tofu $4.00
Pressed Sandwiches
Cubano Roasted pork, black forest ham, swiss, pickles, mayo-chipotle mustard $8.00
Dominicano Ham, cheddar, tomato, red onion, añejo rum ketchup $7.00
Chavorrayo Chicken, avocado, monterrey jack, garlic mayo $8.00
The Meatman Pancetta, provolone, roasted pepper, and black olive paste $8.00
Off the Grill
Marinated Grilled Vegetables Served with hummus and pita bread, dusted with parmasean
  • Add: chicken Price: $4.00 Steak Price: $4.00 Shrimp Price: $5.00 Tofu Price: $4.00 
 $9.00
Jalapeño Turkey Burger Kaiser roll, sautéed onions and peppers, mayo chipotle mustard, mixed greens $7.00
The B.F.B ½ pound black angus, tomatoes, onions and fatty’s special sauce on a kaiser roll, mixed greens. $8.00
Yard Burger Jerk marinated all-beef burger, añejo rum ketchup, cheddar, mixed greens $8.00
Charity Burger Angus burger with avocado, sprouts, garlic aioli, anejo rum ketchup cheese of choice, mixed greens $11.00
Grilled Chicken Sofrito marinated, with a healthy grip of blackened asparagus $10.00
Honey Dijon Chicken Honey, dijon and herb marinated, served with mashed rosemary sweet potatoes $11.00
Grilled Skirt Steak Served with garlic sautéed spinach and Portobello mushrooms and a cilantro-pepper sauce $13.00
Steak Frite Black angus hanger steak topped with shallots and a pat of parsley butter, and of course the frites…fries! $14.00
Salmon Burger Fresh minced salmon with peppers and onions on a kaiser roll topped with wasabi mayo, served with iceberg, cucumber, sprouts and carrot-tahini dressing $10.00
Fatty's Delights
Chofan Stir-fry style vegetables over white rice
  • vegetable $10.00
  • tofu $11.00
  • chicken $12.00
  • beef $12.00
  • shrimp $14.00
Fatty's Burrito A big fat tortilla stuffed with rice, beans, peppers, onions, cheese and your choice of:
  • Vegetable $7.00
  • black bean $7.00
  • chicken $9.00
  • steak $9.00
Chuletas Pan seared center cut pork chops rubbed with garlic and citrus, served with rice, refried black beans and queso blanco $11.00
Citrus Glazed Salmon Pan seared and served in a reduction of citrus juices, Pernod, and butter, with sautéed mixed vegetables finished in white wine $12.00
Panko Breaded Catfish Served with yucca fries and chipotle mayo $13.00
Crab Cake Sandwich Two crab cake patties stuffed in pita with baby spinach and tartar sauce, mixed greens $9.00
Pasta Primavera Nice and light-plain or with choice of grilled chicken or shrimp
  • plain $10.00
  • chicken $12.00
  • shrimp $14.00
Sides
Tostones or maduros  $3.00
Sweet Potato Fries  $4.00
Blackened Asparagus  $4.00
Garlic mashed potato w/sour cream and red onion  $4.00
French fries  $3.00
Rice & beans  $3.00
Sauteed garlic spinach  $4.00
Desserts
Price: $5.00
Vanilla flan 
Tiramisu 
Chocolate tres leches 
Apple walnut cake 
Apple almond cake 
MENU DISCLAIMER
Menu items and prices are subject to change.