The Fish Store

  • Seafood
  • Bayport
836 Montauk Hwy. (Bayport Ave.)Bayport, NY 11705www.thefishstoreonline.com
  • 631-472-3018

Zagat Ratings & Review

Unlock these scores for the real story.

Food Decor Service Cost

Trusted Zagat Ratings and Reviews help take the guesswork out of finding the perfect restaurant.

Stats

# of Reviews:
8
Members Been Here:
1
Member Favorites:
1

Member Reviews

Most Recent Reviews

  • Sorry, Seth, I have to amend my review. It's one thing to raise all your takeout prices, to cut back on the size of the portions on the dinners is another. It just isn't the deal it once was. The New England clam chowder is still awesome and a lobster tail dinner is always a treat.

    Was this review helpful?
  • This is my second time here once for lunch and now dinner,nothing fancy as to the atmosphere however, the food was fresh and very tasty. I had the steamed lobster, steamer clam and mussel dish and was very happy with it. I was even able to change corn for a nice salad. The wait staff was very good...Don't want to, dress fancy, don't care that the window view is the parking lot, why not try this place.

    Was this review helpful?
  • Ordered lobsters to go for wife's birthday. We received large perfectly prepared, cracked and stuffed lobsters ready to finish last 10 minutes of heat and enjoy. All staff very helpful. They made it a memorable meal. The store is newly remodeled and expanded with seating for meals.

    Was this review helpful?
    • Foodie

    This is a fish store that offers a few takeout items. I have occasionally walked out because the fish is not always fresh.

    Was this review helpful?
  • Fish that is never fresh, and poor, limited selection. Cooked food only average. They try mightily but they always fall short. Nothing else around to choose from so as a consumer you're stuck. Better to drive to Citarella's out East and buy up.

    Was this review helpful?

Good to Know

Features
Takeout Available
Meals
Lunch Served
Dinner Served
Signature Dishes
Lobster Marinara: Lobster, Clams, Mussels, Shrimp and Scallops in a Homemade Sweet or Spicy Sauce served over Pasta
Fresh Seafood Straight from the Market