Fishbar on the Lake

  • Seafood
  • Montauk
Gone Fishing Marina467 E. Lake Dr. (opp. Montauk Airport)Long Island, NY 11954www.freshlocalfish.com
  • 631-668-6600

Zagat Ratings & Review

Unlock these scores for the real story.

Food Decor Service Cost

Trusted Zagat Ratings and Reviews help take the guesswork out of finding the perfect restaurant.

Stats

# of Reviews:
39
Seafood Rank:
103 of 135
Montauk Rank:
20 of 24
Members Been Here:
1
Member Favorites:
2

Member Reviews

Most Recent Reviews

  • A great seafood bar and restaurant on the lake. Highly recommended

    Was this review helpful?
  • While this usedto be a good value for fresh seafood, the last visit taking advantage of the "lobster for three" special produced lobsters that were barely a pound each. For the $40 per person it cost, each person received about $10 worth of lobster and assorted overcooked shrimp, mussels and corn. Just not worth the wait or the cost.

    Was this review helpful?
  • Very, very fresh seafood shines. Creative renditions of old favorites like fish tacos and a superb lobster roll ate the clear winners here

    Was this review helpful?
  • Love the food and the view!

    Was this review helpful?
  • A hidden gem. The food is amazing, you are at a marina so it's a cool spot, and it is not too trendy and annoying, as many of the places out east have become. And the owners are so great! I recommend this place to anyone who comes out to Montauk. It's a place like no other out there.

    Was this review helpful?

Good to Know

Features
Lake/Pond
Natural/Organic Ingredients
Patio
Takeout Available
View
Meals
Dinner Served
Signature Dishes
Hoppin' John: New Orleans Scallop Dish
Tilefish With Baby Vegetables & Beurre Blanc

Related Buzz » Blog Posts about Fishbar on the Lake