The Fishery

  • Seafood
  • East Rockaway
1 Main St. (Atlantic Ave.)East Rockaway, NY 11518www.thefishery.kpsearch.com
  • 516-256-7117

Zagat Ratings & Review

Unlock these scores for the real story.

Food Decor Service Cost

Trusted Zagat Ratings and Reviews help take the guesswork out of finding the perfect restaurant.

Stats

# of Reviews:
240
Seafood Rank:
90 of 135
East Rockaway Rank:
1 of 1
Members Been Here:
4
Member Favorites:
1

Member Reviews

Most Recent Reviews

  • THERE WAS A BUG IN MY FOOD!!!!
    I just recently ate there this week. Everything was going well until I was packing my to go box. In the middle of transferring the food into the box, there was a roach in the box with my food. When I called the waitress to the table she quickly got rid of the box and came back with the check. She tried to completely ignore the issue. I then asked for the manager and the manager came over with her arms folded like

    Was this review helpful?
  • The food is OK, and the waitstaff is fine, but I will not be returning.
    The last two times I tried to dine there we were shown to tables that should not have existed. One was outside, adjacent to the parking lot and the restaurant's trash cans. The other was in a dank room in the rear of the restaurant, adjacent to the bathrooms and a wait station. There seemed to be plenty of open tables, but they try to fill the worst first. And pay to park?

    Was this review helpful?
  • first off food ok but decor reminded me cross between a diner and school cafeteria!! one bathroom for each sex..found girl in men's room..not good!! bartenders good service good prices were high however!! bands here that stunk!! avoid rock candy and mainstreet..absolutely awful!! YOU NOW MUST PAY TO PARK HERE!!!..tell the gals to be careful if they wear heels..parking lot is treacherous!! not much of a dance floor either..ALRIGHT AS LAST RESORT.

    Was this review helpful?
    • Premium Member

    Food was excellent however the atmosphere was too crowded, too loud and a little unorderly. The food was superb and I definitely will return!

    Was this review helpful?
    • Foodie

    Have had lunch here twice. Both experiences were good but not great, with most dishes just slightly above average. Only exception was the New Orleans Po Boy which tasted like something you'd get at Long John Silver's. I know a few people that rave about this place, so will give it one more chance to impress.

    Was this review helpful?

Good to Know

Features
Live Entertainment
Takeout Available
Terrace/Deck
View
Waterside
Meals
Lunch Served
Dinner Served
Signature Dishes
Seared Ginger Teriyaki Tuna
Sun Dried Tomato & Herb Crusted Chilean Sea Bass