Island Burgers & Shakes

Burger | West 50s

Food21 Decor12 Service18 Cost$19

Ratings are out of 30. Key to ratings Question

Zagat ratings

Zagat calculates ratings on a 30-point scale based on periodic consumer surveys

26 - 30
Extraordinary to Perfection
21 - 25
Very Good to Excellent
16 - 20
Good to Very Good
11 - 15
Fair to Good
0 - 10
Poor to Fair

"Huge burgers" on "big buns" accessorized with "every topping known to man" are the raisons d'être of these "retro" West Side patty palaces that "finally sell fries" too; "spoon-licking shakes" sweeten the sour taste left by "sparse seating and service."

Learn how Zagat writes reviews »