Island Restaurant
Seafood | East 90s
Food19
Decor18
Service19
Cost$49
Ratings are out of 30. Key to ratings Question Zagat ratings
Zagat calculates ratings on a 30-point scale based on periodic consumer surveys
- 26 - 30
- Extraordinary to Perfection
- 21 - 25
- Very Good to Excellent
- 16 - 20
- Good to Very Good
- 11 - 15
- Fair to Good
- 0 - 10
- Poor to Fair
Carnegie Hill locals appreciate this "reliable neighborhood spot" for its midpriced American menu starring "solid" seafood dishes; the "cozy" space, decorated "like a yacht club", manages to be "elegant without being stuffy", but it "always seems to be crowded", so "make a reservation or come early."
