Milk & Sugar Café
- American (Traditional)
- Bay Shore
- 631-969-3655
Stats
- # of Reviews:
- 145
- American (Traditional) Rank:
- 25 of 109
- Bay Shore Rank:
- 8 of 11
- Members Been Here:
- 4
- Member Favorites:
- 1
Member Reviews
Most Recent Reviews
-
Saturday Lunch. Patrons 98% female. Artichoke Dip watered down. Had Filet Mignon/Asparagus/Gorgonzola Mashed Potatoes. Filet was perfect. Asparagus good. Potatoes tasteless over-boiled or mixed with instant and lacking any hint of Gorgonzola cheese. Place was packed and noisy. Entire staff was very friendly. Warning: They serve humongous portions of everything so consider sharing. I plan to return soon. Good pickup place.
Published November 19, 2011 -
From the snotty hostesses' to the spotty service this place has gone down hill since first opening. The staff should try the "humble" sandwich. Consider yourself blessed if they thank you on the way out!
Published October 30, 2011 -
HORRIBLE!!HORRIBLE!!!!! This is a warning to anyone who is considering planning an event at Milk & Sugar..The Victorican Room..this is a warning...don't be fooled by the decorations or atmosphere...after three months of planning my sisters Bridal shower...three months....we get a call from the owner that he double booked...double booked..WTF...after three months and with only three weeks of planning...so realize this...we signed a contract...yes
Published July 7, 2011 -
Creative food, relaxing atmosphere. Cute lunch spot.
Published November 17, 2010 -
Perfect spot!Food is a little eclectic but just interesting enough for a foodie without being too wierd. Love all the appys. Try the filet they do a great job with it. You must view the desserts! Trying to choose just one will be difficult and they change with the seasons as does the menu. Also excellent lunch spot! Take time to linger on the big couches.
Published November 17, 2010
Good to Know
- Features
- Fireplace
Private Room Available
Sidewalk
Takeout Available
- Meals
- Breakfast Served
Lunch Served
Dinner Served
- Signature Dishes
- Meatloaf
Penne Caprice; Wraps
Nov. 2011