Mill Creek Tavern

Seafood, Steakhouse
Bayville

275 Bayville Ave. (Pine Park Ave.)Bayville, NY 11709www.millcreekny.com

516-628-2000

Zagat Ratings & Review

Unlock these scores for the real story.

Food	Decor	Service	Cost

Trusted Zagat Ratings and Reviews help take the guesswork out of finding the perfect restaurant.

Stats

# of Reviews:: 85
Seafood Rank:: 43 of 135
Bayville Rank:: 3 of 8
Members Been Here:: 1
Member Favorites:: 2

Add to Lists

Added! Go to List »

Member Reviews

See Reviews From Other Publications

Most Recent Reviews

Omar J

2 Reviews

Member since:
Apr. 2012
wine down wednesday rocks. what a bargain!!

Published April 3, 2012
Was this review helpful?
Yes No
- Report This
lyn g

8 Reviews

Bayville

Member since:
Oct. 2010
good comfort food. A great local place for dinner & drinkswith friends.One of our favorit places.

Published November 15, 2010
Was this review helpful?
Yes No
- Report This
sherry g

46 Reviews

Plainview

Member since:
Apr. 2009
Like mim's just a different location. Reliable homey food.

Published November 11, 2010
Was this review helpful?
Yes No
- Report This
MAUREEN B

2 Reviews

Sea Cliff

Member since:
Nov. 2007
What a cozy spot. with the fireplace going and such a wondeerful artichoke and steak dinner along with homemade pumpkin pudding with cinnamon ice cream.If you visit check out their regular menu susch a variety shore to please everyone..Sue

Published November 11, 2010
Was this review helpful?
Yes No
- Report This
Dane W

25 Reviews

East Norwich

Member since:
Oct. 2008
Good value.

Published November 9, 2010
Was this review helpful?
Yes No
- Report This

See all 55 reviews »

Good to Know

Features: Fireplace
Live Entertainment
Private Room Available
Takeout Available

Meals: Dinner Served

Signature Dishes: Mussel Pots: Two Pounds Of Six Different Types Of Mussels With Different Sauce Choices; 22 Oz. Cowboy Steak
Escargots; Sea Scallops In Rissotto