Nonnina
- Italian
- West Islip
- 631-321-8717
Make a Reservation
Stats
- # of Reviews:
- 78
- Italian Rank:
- 18 of 212
- West Islip Rank:
- 1 of 3
- Members Been Here:
- 4
- Member Favorites:
- 2
Member Reviews
Most Recent Reviews
-
decor, food & service are all on target here. there are 3 dining areas & while each has it's own vibe they are all lovely. upstairs is cozy, tables in the bar are a bit more upbeat and the downstairs dining room is beautiful with a subdued atmosphere. service is good without being overbearing & despite having a saturday night 8pm reservation, we were not rushed, nor did we have to wait. generous portions of beautifully presented dishes.
Published June 27, 2011 -
Unprofessional and poorly trained staff coupled with a smug and haughty manager leaves the customer with a bad taste in his mouth. Overcooked pasta, rubbery seafood, and over salted dishes makes this restaurant a "never again" for me.
Long Island has so much better to offer. Try Il Mulino in Roslyn or Ubaldo's in Farmingdale for authentic Italian cuisine and a charming atmosphere.
Published April 17, 2011 -
The food is very good, especially the veal meatball app. However, I could do without the used-car-salesman-like attitude of the waiters.
Published November 21, 2010 -
Great food and wine
Published November 20, 2010 -
If you love Manhattan but don't feel like making the hike on a weekend, Noninna is the place to be. The service,decor and food are all equally impeccable. I always feel like I got back from vacation after an evening spent there!
Published November 20, 2010
Good to Know
- Features
- Dramatic Interiors
Fireplace
Private Room Available
Takeout Available
- Meals
- Lunch Served
Dinner Served
- Signature Dishes
- Lobster Pasta
Branzino (Whole Fish)
Jan. 2006