The Pie at Salvatore's

  • Pizza
  • Bay Shore
120 E. Main St. (bet. 1st & 2nd Aves.)Bay Shore, NY 11706www.salvatorescoalfiredpizza.com
  • 631-206-1060

Zagat Ratings & Review

Unlock these scores for the real story.

Food Decor Service Cost

Trusted Zagat Ratings and Reviews help take the guesswork out of finding the perfect restaurant.

Stats

# of Reviews:
40
Pizza Rank:
1 of 51
Bay Shore Rank:
4 of 11
Members Been Here:
5
Member Favorites:
3

Member Reviews

Most Recent Reviews

  • Great pizza and great caesar too!

    Was this review helpful?
    • Premium Member

    If you've had pizza in Rome, this is about as close as you can get on Long Island. Enough said. If you haven't been to Rome, you should. When you get back go to Salvatore's.

    Was this review helpful?
    • Premium Member

    This is by far the best pizza I've ever had. It is so good that it is addicting. Using the freshest ingredients each pie comes out of the coal fired oven as a work of art. I've brought many friends in for a casual dinner and the response is always the same - wow!

    Was this review helpful?
  • What more can you ask for, great pizza with shrimp scampi topping is my favorite. If you are not in the mood for pizza go for the meatballs, eggplant parm. or the baked zit, all excellent. Have a glass of Chainti with it and you will feel like you are on vacation in Italy.

    Was this review helpful?
  • Wow!!!! the pizza was awsome... the thin crust the cheese all a nice touch. Everything was delish!! I wish though that the price was lower. 20.00* for pizza.. But, It is wort the money!

    Was this review helpful?

Good to Know

Features
Patio
Private Room Available
Takeout Available
Meals
Lunch Served
Dinner Served
Signature Dishes
Brick Oven Pizza
Homemade Pastas