Pine Grove Inn

  • Eclectic / Int'l
  • East Patchogue
1 First StreetEast Patchogue, NY 11772
  • 631-475-9843
This restaurant was added by Nicole N on 09/23/2007.

Help this restaurant to be considered for a Zagat Rating by adding your member review.

Stats

# of Reviews:
9
Members Been Here:
0
Member Favorites:
0

Member Reviews

Most Recent Reviews

    • Foodie
    • Premium Member

    I've gone to the PGI 2 or 3 times a year for the past 10 years. The food is always very good - and sometimes it's phenomenal. I'm always happy with the duck - and when they have soft shell crab - get it. I try and alternate between German and Continental menu items each time I go. The servers are usually very nice, helpful and efficient. The decor is just OK, a little old fashioned. The men's room - as someone else said - needs a reno badly.

    Published October 4, 2010
    Was this review helpful?

  • Truly wish I didn't Waste my money. 1:45 min still no entre. German food, my reason for going. Frozen potato pancake, Un believable small portion totally covered by gravy. Potato ball sticky no taste NOT LIKE GRANDMA. Don't waste your time or money. Truly forgetable.

    Published April 17, 2010
    Was this review helpful?
    • Premium Member

    As with previous visits, I didn't like it this time either. My wife's chicken was extremely dry and my steak tasted awful. I've gone when other family members wanted to for some occasion. I have nothing against the place or its proprietors; I've just never had a good meal there. The mashed potatoes are OK though.

    Published February 12, 2010
    Was this review helpful?

  • Man, if a restaurant ever needed a makeover, it is The Pine Grove Inn.
    Fabulous - truly outstanding, food and excellent cocktails (the bartender, Dana, may be the best mixologist working in Suffolk) are marred by a rundown, tired decor. The men's room is a disgrace - reminiscent of an elementary school lavatory - hardly what you'd expect when shelling out better than $170 for dinner for two.
    Food - Excellent
    Ambience? You've got to be kidding!

    Published January 30, 2010
    Was this review helpful?
    • Foodie

    I go to the Pine Grove Inn once a year. If it's in the winter I usually have their old fashioned German food, but in the warmer months their excellent sea food is a far better choice.

    Published July 25, 2009
    Was this review helpful?
See all 9 reviews »

Good to Know

Features
Dancing
Live Entertainment
Outdoor Seating
Private Room Available
Meals
Brunch Served
Lunch Served
Dinner Served