P.J. Clarke's

American | West 60s

Food17 Decor16 Service17 Cost$39

Ratings are out of 30. Key to ratings Question

Zagat ratings

Zagat calculates ratings on a 30-point scale based on periodic consumer surveys

26 - 30
Extraordinary to Perfection
21 - 25
Very Good to Excellent
16 - 20
Good to Very Good
11 - 15
Fair to Good
0 - 10
Poor to Fair

A bastion of "old NY coolness", this circa-1884 Midtown saloon is renowned for its "super-duper" burgers, "historic ambiance" and "fun bar scene"; while the newer spin-offs "don't have the charm" of the original, the Lincoln Center outpost offers pre-theater convenience, while the FiDi branch boasts "lovely water views."

Learn how Zagat writes reviews »