Plaza Cafe is cozy, lovely, and truly enjoyable. Everything from the service to the dessert was phenomenal. The staff are kind and fun, but know when to leave you alone. The cocktails, apps, entrees and desserts are flawless. We can't wait to go back. Exceptional.
"Couldn't improve on anything." Everything about the Plaza Cafe was flawless. From the hospitable waitstaff, the pleasant surrounding and exceptional taste and presentation of each course. I won't hesitate to return and encourage all to do the same.
i have been to many restaurants in the hamptons-in my experience-this is by far the best-the food is incredible,service is great --i cant find any fault with the plaza cafe and i will continue to return there for great dining.
My boyfriend and I went out in Southampton in search of an amazing food experience and we were successful in finding The Plaza Cafe, thanks to a recommendation from a local bartender. We shared the Tuna and Crab Tian as an appetizer which was light and flavorful. I had the gulf shrimp with pesto pasta and my boyfriend had the sauteed scallops. We were both impressed by our dishes and our only regret was that we didn't save room for dessert!
The entrees were tasteless old plate presentation and for sure not fresh. I'm not going back for sure
Sep. 2012