Totonno Pizzeria Napolitana
Pizza | Coney Island
Food25
Decor11
Service16
Cost$21
Ratings are out of 30. Key to ratings Question Zagat ratings
Zagat calculates ratings on a 30-point scale based on periodic consumer surveys
- 26 - 30
- Extraordinary to Perfection
- 21 - 25
- Very Good to Excellent
- 16 - 20
- Good to Very Good
- 11 - 15
- Fair to Good
- 0 - 10
- Poor to Fair
Surviving a recent flood and fire, this seemingly indestructible 90-year-old pizzeria remains a Coney Island "legend" thanks to "incredible" coal-oven pies dispatched in a no-frills, "family-run" milieu; despite no slices, no plastic and "slow" service, fans say it's "classic Brooklyn" at its best.
