Varney's

  • American (Traditional), Seafood
  • Brookhaven
2109 Montauk Hwy. (Westminster Ave.)Brookhaven, NY 11719www.varneysrestaurant.com
  • 631-286-9569

Zagat Ratings & Review

Unlock these scores for the real story.

Food Decor Service Cost

Trusted Zagat Ratings and Reviews help take the guesswork out of finding the perfect restaurant.

Stats

# of Reviews:
83
American (Traditional) Rank:
13 of 109
Brookhaven Rank:
3 of 17
Members Been Here:
3
Member Favorites:
2

Member Reviews

Most Recent Reviews

  • Great mussels! Their seafood is fresh flavorful.

    Was this review helpful?
  • no nonsense decor and great food - especially those mussels! they are the best around.

    Was this review helpful?
  • this small and quaint spot in the middle of nowhere has the best mussels I have ever had,not to mention killer sandwiches and seafood specials. Be prepared for a lesurely lunch and enjoy the local crowd

    Was this review helpful?
  • A little gem. When busy be prepared to wait as service only moves as fast as the kitchen can get the food out...but worth the wait.

    Was this review helpful?
  • Don't drive by and don't let the beach shack look fool you. With six burners in the tiny kitchen, the Varney's crew serves food like no where else on Long Island. Consistently excellent, always palate pleasing with persnickity service. A repeat spot for smart diners.

    Was this review helpful?

Good to Know

Features
Patio
Takeout Available
Meals
Lunch Served
Dinner Served
Signature Dishes
Seafood Fra Diavolo
Mussles In Red Or White Sauce