Vine Street Café
- American (Traditional)
- Shelter Island
- 631-749-3210
Make a Reservation
Stats
- # of Reviews:
- 162
- American (Traditional) Rank:
- 5 of 109
- Shelter Island Rank:
- 1 of 9
- Members Been Here:
- 4
- Member Favorites:
- 3
Member Reviews
Most Recent Reviews
-
This is what every restaurant on Shelter Island should aspire to, no matter what the target meal price is. It proves what creative, thoughtful dedication to great food and service should be. Not that it's perfect for highly critical diners who can always find fault. Simple, fresh, with careful presentation always wins in the end. FYI: the jalapeno margarita with fresh lime and orange juice, silver tequila is as close to perfect as you can get.
Published September 3, 2012 -
Limited, not especially creative, choices, but most superbly prepared. Plain, roadhouse style decor, with too many hard surfaces (noisy when busy; the back room is quieter). Dimly lit -- we sometimes need a flashlight to read the menu, and I once left too small a tip because I misread the bill. Service varies in our experience.
Published May 14, 2012 -
The restaurant is a breath of fresh air to the hectic nightlife of the Hampton's. The food is great and they do honor a reservation.
Published September 19, 2011 -
Don't know what all thehype is about - it's good, not great with long waits in the summer.
Published November 20, 2010 -
- Premium Member
Alway have great food and service. It is on Shelter Island, but worth the trip.
Published November 13, 2010
Good to Know
- Features
- Game Served
Natural/Organic Ingredients
Private Room Available
Takeout Available
Terrace/Deck
- Meals
- Dinner Served
- Signature Dishes
- Bouillabaisse, Steak Frites
Duck Confit
Aug. 2012