Water Street Restaurant

  • American (New)
  • Nantucket
21 S Water StNantucket, MA 02554
  • 508-228-7080
This restaurant was added by Stonelady on 06/06/2007.

Help this restaurant to be considered for a Zagat Rating by adding your member review.

Stats

# of Reviews:
6
Members Been Here:
0
Member Favorites:
0

Member Reviews

Most Recent Reviews

  • Food is wonderful and atmosphere terrific. Ate there three times when on the island. Upstairs and downstairs give two unique experiences. Compared to many places on Nantucket the price was more than worth it.

    Published August 26, 2007
    Was this review helpful?

  • Comfortable, yet elegant. Downstairs is divinely romantic, and upstairs is crisp and hopping. Regardless, the food is the best on the island, bar none.

    Published August 26, 2007
    Was this review helpful?
    • Premium Member

    Two husband and wife teams own, cook, and serve at this warm, romantic jewel of a restaurant. Downstairs, the knowledgeable servers, who are often the owners, guide you through the menu. The food is prepared with passion and care. The ingredients are local and organic whenever possible, but the flavors are out of this world. Wine list is reasonably priced and eclectic. Upstairs, the bartender, Graydon, a Nantucket legend, mixes the best drinks on the island. The bar is both elegant and friendly at the same time.Terrific bar food is available at a lower price. Why are so many chefs eating here?

    Published June 6, 2007
    Was this review helpful?

  • Exquisite food, beautiful room. Recommended to me by knowledgeable local chef. Bar upstairs is great fun, too. Robert and Jason are producing food that is a step up for the island. I highly recommend it.

    Published June 6, 2007
    Was this review helpful?
See all 4 reviews »

Good to Know

Meals
Dinner Served