The Fancy; Mike & Patty's
This tiny Bay Village sandwich shop has only a few seats, yet legions of dedicated locals know it has some of the best, most creative sammies around. And plenty of commuting pedestrians stop in to grab the famous Fancy on their way to the office; the breakfast sandwich is stuffed with a fried egg, bacon, cheddar, avocado, red onion and house mayo.
Insider Tip: Mike & Patty's closes at 2 PM on weekdays, and our anecdotal research suggests that 10:30 AM might be the best time to avoid lines. It seems to be the perfect "miss breakfast buyers, beat lunch crowd" point in time.