Third-generation owner Jack Miller makes his 20+ flavors special by making his own ice cream mix-ins, like fudge-y brownies and cheesecake. He also has crowd-pleasers in stock, like Oreo, Nutella and Reese's peanut butter cups.
Must-Order: The salted caramel is spot on: not too sweet, with a ribbon of the sticky goo running throughout. You can get two flavors in the small cup, so pile on the brownie ice cream too. It has giant chunks of cakey goodness throughout.
Go Crazy!: This counter has gotten too busy to make sundaes, so DIY at home. There are 30 flavors available in half-gallon containers.