Best of the Best

Long Island's Most Popular

Zagat users’ favorite restaurants in Long Island based on our most recent survey.

Peter Luger's

SteakhouseGreat Neck
4.6
Food
3.8
Decor
4.2
Service

West End Cafe

AmericanCarle Place
4.5
Food
4
Decor
4.3
Service

Tellers Restaurant: An American Chophouse

SteakhouseIslip
4.7
Food
4.7
Decor
4.7
Service

Prime

AmericanHuntington
4.6
Food
4.8
Decor
4.5
Service

Besito

MexicanHuntington
4.4
Food
4.3
Decor
4.3
Service

Besito Mexican Restaurant - Roslyn, NY

MexicanRoslyn
4.4
Food
4.3
Decor
4.3
Service

Bryant & Cooper Steak House

Roslyn
4.5
Food
4
Decor
4.4
Service

Blackstone Steakhouse

SteakhouseMelville
4.5
Food
4.5
Decor
4.5
Service

Waterzooi Belgian Bistro & Oyster Bar

BelgianGarden City
4.4
Food
3.9
Decor
4.1
Service

Maureen's Kitchen

AmericanSmithtown
4.7
Food
4.2
Decor
4.4
Service

North Fork Table & Inn

Food CourtSouthold
4.8
Food
4.5
Decor
4.7
Service

Kotobuki Restaurant

Babylon
4.6
Food
3.7
Decor
4.1
Service

Kotobuki

Hauppauge
4.6
Food
3.7
Decor
4.1
Service

Kotobuki

JapaneseRoslyn
4.6
Food
3.7
Decor
4.1
Service

Rothmann's Steakhouse

SteakhouseEast Norwich
4.5
Food
4.2
Decor
4.4
Service

Il Mulino

ItalianRoslyn
4.6
Food
4.3
Decor
4.3
Service

H2O: Seafood & Sushi

SeafoodSmithtown
4.5
Food
4.3
Decor
4.4
Service

Jewel Restaurant

AmericanMelville
4.3
Food
4.7
Decor
4.2
Service
You’re missing out—

The Zagat app will help you find the best places, faster.

Try it! No thanks
Looking for a great place?

Find it faster with the new Zagat app

No thanks Try it!