Review NYC restaurants and get a free restaurants guide!    Start Now »


Rosenthal Wine Merchant

Food Store | East 80s

This place has CLOSED

Quality29 Appeal23 Service26 CostE
Ratings are out of 30. Key to ratings Question  
Zagat ratings

Zagat calculates ratings on a 30-point scale based on periodic consumer surveys

  • 26 - 30
  • Extraordinary to Perfection
  • 21 - 25
  • Very Good to Excellent
  • 16 - 20
  • Good to Very Good
  • 11 - 15
  • Fair to Good
  • 0 - 10
  • Poor to Fair
  • I
  • Inexpensive
  • M
  • Moderate
  • E
  • Expensive
  • VE
  • Very Expensive

Numerical cost estimates are for the price of dinner with one drink and tip.

Our Summary Review

You “feel like you’re part of a club” when you step into the brownstone that houses this “old-school” Upper East Side wine shop, where there’s “always an interesting selection” of small, artisanal French and Italian producers and other “fine wines you can’t get anyplace else”, all imported by merchant Neal Rosenthal (who has no official affiliation with the store); “flawless” guidance will lead you to bottles “you’ve never heard of” yet “love from the first taste” – just know that help from the “best palates” doesn’t come cheap.

318 E 84th St | Map
New York, New York 10028


Rosenthal Wine Merchant

318 E 84th St
New York, New York 10028

MORE ABOUT Rosenthal Wine Merchant

You Might Also Like